The IASP nociplastic pain checklist confirms better than it rules out
- A University of Thessaly team tested the IASP clinical criteria and grading system for nociplastic pain on 32 clinical vignettes built from real patients with chronic musculoskeletal pain of the neck, shoulder, low back and knee, eight per area.
- Two musculoskeletal physiotherapists rated every vignette twice, one month apart; intra-rater agreement was moderate to perfect (κ = 0.71–1.00, p < 0.05) and inter-rater agreement weak to perfect (κ = 0.52–1.00, p < 0.05).
- Inter-rater agreement fell from κ = 0.81–1.00 right after training to κ = 0.52–1.00 at the second rating, a month later.
- Against the reference classification, criterion validity was moderate (κ = 0.68), with specificity of 89.0%, sensitivity of 69.0%, and positive and negative predictive values of 81.8% and 81.0%.
A Greek team tested the IASP clinical criteria for nociplastic pain on 32 written patient cases and found that they confirm the label more reliably than they rule it out. The criteria were written to give pain without tissue findings a positive description, so that a referral no longer reads, in effect, "nothing found, see a psychologist".
A shared vocabulary with the referring doctor
The checklist asks a short series of questions. Is the pain regional rather than discrete? Is there evidence of nociceptive or neuropathic pain, and does either fully explain the picture? Are there evoked hypersensitivity phenomena, a history of pain hypersensitivity, comorbidities? The answer ends in one of three grades: no, possible or probable nociplastic pain.
Raters trained on the criteria agreed well, especially soon after training. A month later their agreement on whether nociceptive pain was present dropped to κ = 0.52. That question asks the clinician to judge tissue findings, and it is the one a psychologist cannot answer alone.
The numbers carry a practical asymmetry. With 89.0% specificity, a "probable" grade is a fairly safe label. With 69.0% sensitivity, roughly three in ten nociplastic cases in this set were missed. A "no" from the checklist does not prove that the nervous system is not amplifying the pain.
For a psychologist, the value is less the score than the language. "Nociplastic pain, graded probable" is a phrase a rheumatologist or physiotherapist recognises, and it places the client's pain in a mechanism rather than in a diagnosis by exclusion. Ask the referring doctor which grade they reached and how they answered the nociceptive question. That gives the first session a shared starting point.
A probable grade on the IASP checklist names a pain mechanism, so the client no longer arrives with pain that is psychological by default.
The study used written vignettes, not live patients, and only two physiotherapist raters. There is no universally accepted reference standard for nociplastic pain, so accuracy was measured against the vignettes' prior classification.
- nociplastic pain
- IASP criteria
- chronic musculoskeletal pain
- central sensitisation
- interprofessional referral