The brain's control network runs quieter during favourite short videos
- A preregistered study from Zhejiang University combined functional MRI during free viewing of short videos with resting proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy of the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) in 56 young adults.
- The dACC and the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC) showed significant deactivation during preferred videos watched to completion, compared with less-preferred videos that were stopped early.
- Higher resting glutamate in the dACC was associated with less suppression of activity in both the dACC and the dlPFC.
- Functional connectivity between the dACC and the dlPFC increased during viewing, particularly for preferred videos.
A team from the Department of Psychology and Behavioral Sciences at Zhejiang University scanned 56 young adults while they watched short videos freely, finishing or skipping each clip as they chose. The comparison that matters is between clips people let run to the end and clips they abandoned.
Fifty-six volunteers, two kinds of clip
The 56 young adults watched short videos inside an MRI scanner under free viewing: a video could run to the end or be cut short. Before the task, proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy measured resting concentrations of glutamate and GABA, the main excitatory and inhibitory neurotransmitters, in the dACC. Functional MRI then tracked two regions, the dACC and the dlPFC. Both belong to the cognitive control network, which is active when a task demands effort. The protocol was preregistered.
A difference between conditions
Activity in both regions dropped while people watched preferred videos to the end, compared with less-preferred videos they abandoned. Connectivity between the two regions rose during viewing, most of all for the preferred clips. The authors describe the pattern as deactivation of the cognitive control network during immersive viewing.
Where individual differences come in
Resting glutamate in the dACC tracked how far activity fell. People with higher glutamate concentrations showed less suppression, in the dACC and in the dlPFC alike.
My reading is that the autopilot clients describe may have a measurable correlate, though these were young adults in a scanner, not clients. The study links lower control-network activity to preferred, completed clips; it cannot say whether the clip lowers control or lower control keeps the clip running. Either way, asking a client for more willpower in the middle of a feed asks for a resource that is running low at that moment. I would move the decision outside the clip: agree on a stopping rule before the app opens and switch off autoplay, so the choice to continue falls in the gap between videos. The glutamate finding adds one more point for the assessment. The study did not measure how hard people find it to stop, but the individual differences suggest a question worth asking: how hard stopping feels, not only how long the viewing lasts.
In the scanner, the brain's control regions went quieter during favourite short videos watched to the end, and less so in people with higher resting glutamate in the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex.
The sample was 56 young adults scanned in a laboratory session, not people seeking help for problematic use. The full text is behind a paywall, and this note is based on the published abstract.
- short videos
- cognitive control
- fMRI
- glutamate
- self-regulation