In early adolescents, an account hidden from parents carries the strongest social media addiction signal
- Cross-sectional data from the ABCD Study covered 5,639 US youth aged 10 to 13 with a social media account; TikTok was the most-used platform for 1,471 (26.25%), and 254 (4.53%) reported an account kept secret from their parents.
- On the six-item Social Media Addiction Questionnaire, scores ranged from 6 to 36 (mean 10.99); 13.0% scored 18 or more, the level reached by answering "rarely" or more often to every item.
- In the fully adjusted model, a secret account was associated with higher scores (b = 2.27, 95% CI 1.65–2.89), as were TikTok as the most-used platform compared with YouTube (b = 1.52), a public account (b = 0.85) and more daily hours on social media (b = 0.66).
- The authors state that social media addiction is not an established clinical disorder; the questionnaire covers addiction-like features such as salience, mood modification, withdrawal and conflict.
Talk about a young adolescent's phone usually turns on hours and apps. A team led by Jacob Hermann at New York University used ABCD Study data to add two more: whether the account is public, and whether the parents know it exists.
Platform, hours and settings
The data come from the two-year follow-up of the ABCD Study, collected between July 2018 and January 2021, at ages 10.8 to 14.0; 29% of the answers were given during the COVID-19 pandemic. Each child named a most-used platform, reported daily hours across all social media and answered six items on salience, mood modification, tolerance, withdrawal, conflict and relapse, each scored from 1 to 6. The authors state plainly that social media addiction is not an established clinical disorder and that the term does not imply an equivalent of substance addiction.
The account parents do not know about
Children whose main platform was TikTok had the highest mean score, 12.25 against 10.43 for YouTube. More daily hours went with higher scores. The largest coefficient in the fully adjusted model, however, belonged to the secret account: b = 2.27, against 1.52 for TikTok. Only 254 children, 4.53% of those who answered, had one. Their mean score was 13.69, against 10.84 among the rest. A public account added 0.85, while the number of followers showed no significant association.
In my reading, the secret account is a clinical detail, not a parenting footnote. Ask an 11-year-old how many hours they spend on TikTok and you get a number that self-reports in this cohort tended to underestimate. Ask whether there is an account their parents have never seen, and a yes tells you that some of the child's use already happens out of their parents' sight. Concealment is a sign clinicians look for in any behaviour slipping out of control. I would put that question into the first interview with a young adolescent, ask it without the parents in the room, and treat a yes as the start of a conversation about what the hidden account gives the child. It is not evidence of a disorder, which, as the authors note, has no diagnostic status.
In 5,639 American 10- to 13-year-olds, an account kept secret from parents was associated with a 2.27-point higher addiction score, more than TikTok as the main platform or a public account.
The data are cross-sectional and self-reported, collected between 2018 and 2021, partly during the COVID-19 pandemic. The questionnaire was adapted from the Bergen Facebook Addiction Scale and has not itself been validated.
- social media addiction
- early adolescents
- TikTok
- parental monitoring
- ABCD Study