In construction workers, suicide risk followed pain in the hands and not the back
- Between 1989 and 1993, 79,099 male Swedish construction workers aged 16–62 reported how often they had felt pain in nine body areas over the past year; 55% reported frequent pain in at least one location, most often in the lower back.
- Over an average follow-up of 21.4 years, the registers recorded 1,462 cases of non-fatal self-harm and 271 suicides; compared with no pain, frequent pain in at least one location was associated with a 25% higher risk of non-fatal self-harm (HR 1.25, 95% CI 1.01–1.55) and a doubled risk of suicide (HR 1.97, 95% CI 1.05–3.69).
- Frequent pain in the elbow, wrist or hand was the only regional pain linked to suicide (HR 1.60, 95% CI 1.12–2.29), and the association remained after adjustment for occupational group and unfavourable working positions (HR 1.55, 95% CI 1.07–2.25).
- Frequent lower back pain was not associated with suicide (HR 1.03, 95% CI 0.71–1.49); frequent pain in the knee, ankle or foot was associated with non-fatal self-harm (HR 1.22, 95% CI 1.05–1.41) but not with suicide.
A University of Gothenburg team led by Kirsten Mehlig followed 79,099 Swedish construction workers for up to three decades and counted 271 suicides. The pain that went with them sat in the elbows, wrists and hands, not in the lower back that most people picture first.
A questionnaire from the early nineties
Between 1989 and 1993, men attending routine health examinations at Bygghälsan, the occupational health service for the Swedish construction sector, rated how often they had felt pain in nine body areas over the past year. The researchers grouped the answers into four regions and linked them to hospital and cause-of-death registers up to 2018. Events in the first two years after the examination were excluded, so that an emerging mental illness could not colour the pain reports. Average follow-up was 21.4 years.
Hands, wrists and elbows
Frequent pain somewhere in the body was reported by 55% of the men, most often in the lower back. Against no pain, it went with a 25% higher risk of non-fatal self-harm and a doubled risk of suicide. Split by region, the picture narrowed. Frequent pain in the elbow, wrist or hand was the only kind linked to suicide, with a hazard ratio of 1.60, and it held after adjustment for occupation and working posture. Lower back pain showed no association with suicide. Pain in the knee, ankle or foot was associated with non-fatal self-harm only. The authors note that pain in the hands and feet often signals chronic conditions such as arthritis, diabetes or nerve damage from hand-arm vibration, while back pain may subside within a few months.
Asking where it hurts
When a man from a manual trade mentions pain, I would ask where it sits before deciding how much weight to give it. A sore back is the expected complaint and rarely prompts a second question. Persistent pain in the hands or wrists, in someone whose living depends on them, calls for the brief questions the authors themselves propose: mood, sleep, alcohol and suicidal thoughts. I would ask them in the first session and not wait for the client to raise them; the authors point to the stigma around help-seeking in the construction sector.
Lower back pain was the most common complaint among 79,099 Swedish construction workers but was not associated with suicide; frequent pain in the elbow, wrist or hand was.
The study is observational. Pain was self-reported once, in 1989–1993, without a validated pain measure, and the cohort included men only. Self-harm treated in primary care is not captured in the registers used.
- chronic pain
- suicide
- self-harm
- occupational health
- construction workers